Hmmm well I agree with you except, superchargers make way better power throughout the RPM band, there is no boost lag. I always thought superchargers were easier to maintain, just change the oil when your supposed to.
Its actually quite the opposite. Superchargers consumer power, to make power. So the net gain is less, and can be seen on a dyno graph. Turbos technically, use engine power, but they dont
consumer engine power. So the net gain is larger. And as far as how and when power comes on, thats all about the setup. Ive seen people mis-size their turbos way too often just to see the big number on the graph. And when I say "mis-size" I really mean that they are putting a turbo on thats way too big. What a lot of people dont realize is that if you size the compressor housing and turbine housing correctly, and take the time to research what compressor wheel works best with what housing, etc; You can get a flat torque graph and a beautiful rising hp graph. The power that a supercharger produces typically drops off at the higher rpms because it only produces boost under engine load. Whereas when you're at the top of the rpm range, the engine load decreases. Once a turbo makes boost, it only continue to make boost, or stay where its at, it will never drop off with engine rpms. The one advantage the a blower has is the power it can make between 1k-3k rpms, but after that a turbo blows it away.
Thats a graph of a GT30r on a stock CRV k24 at 9 psi.
Maintaining a supercharger is a pain because there actually
is maintenance to do! Turbos only require the engine oil to be changed ever so often, which gets done any way. Super chargers have special oil to change, and belts to replace, (and slip, often). And you have to buy different pulleys to change the boost. A turbo only requires a quick turn on a knob and a couple of buttons on a control panel.
I could go on. Ive installed a ton of turbos on cars, and regrettably a few superchargers on others, and the turbos always make more power and are way more fun to drive.
~my $.02
I'd also like to add that I'd take a well built, high compression N/A K24 over a turbo motor any day of the week.