They all provide tubes that are probably made in the same company/factory. I have had an ebay tube and K&N filter for prob 2+ years now and have had no issues with it.
I had that one^ The filter is a pos.
something i've been doing for awhile now since i do not want to buy those filter shields lol...
go to dollar store and buy sock pantyhose. Use it as a cover on your filter and cut off the excess. In my opinion it does hardly any blocking to airflow (make sure to stretch it as much as you can without ripping it) but it keeps larger pieces of dirt from sticking/getting to the filter media and makes cleaning the filter easier.