I have decided to go with the Magnesium Metallic (left). I like the look of the Anthracite, but I think it will be too dark overall. I've been comparing these on the car, on the rims, in different lighting, etc like a madman the past few days, and I appreciate everyone's input.
I'll post photos when they get painted, which I hope will be sometime before next week.
Picked up the wheels today, had the grille painted too while I was at it. Anyway, they turned out great, I was literally giddy putting them on the car.
I'll post some photos of them installed when it stops raining. But for now...
haha I promise I'll post photos. I worked a full day, then picked these up, and got them on just before dark...and of course I had to drive on them, lol. So I really didn't get a chance to snap any decent pics, BUT I will.