Whats the offset on the 9.5's? I'm running a 17x9.5 +15 with a 215/45 tire. I had to roll and pull pretty hard to get them to fit and I had to relocate the rear bumper mounting tab.
get em! i would atleast.. its just to bad someone already bet you to the punch.
plus if you later decide you dont like them, then sell em. they sell for more then what you would get em for. and offer him 250 and see if he takes it..